Ok, Obamaniacs (Cali)....

[creekster]

Originally Posted by Cali Coug

That doesn't even make sense. We are clearly not talking about whether the government can illegally take your money (which you imply by suggesting that it is analogous to illegally killing me with a gun).

Does the government have the legal authority, given to it by the people, to redistribute wealth? Answer that and we can get to the SHOULD.

why does he have to answer thqat first? Indeed, they may even collapse intot the same issue, depending on mhy he thinks they shouldn't. His point, I think, which does make some snese, is that the governemtn IS redistributing, so whether he things it is illegal is moot. It is a fact and and he thinks they shouldn't. WHy he thinks they shouoldn't can certainly be aadddressed without crossing the illegality issue, unless they do collapse.


I have bnot rfead thw whole thread, however, so maybe mine doesn't make sense.